Is Social Media Making Us All the Same?
There I was sitting at my desk, back straight,
shoulders slightly forward, rubbing my beard with my hand, and
contemplating what I would write about when it dawned on me! “Write about conformity aka
Social Proof as it relates to Social Media,” I
said to myself. Then I questioned whether or not YouTube had a video
that would help demonstrate the power of groups to influence behavior.
After a few minutes of searching, I discovered the following video to illustrate
the topic of this post. Go ahead and click on the play button now,
please
Welcome back! Are we so easily influenced nowadays? Right now, I want to quickly answer the question I posed in the title of my post. Yes! Yes, we have conformed to the influence of social media! However, the reasons that we have conformed are that we are fulfilling our basic human needs of 1) connecting with others 2) a sense of accomplishment from having influential and large numbers of connections, and 3) a feeling of uniqueness because of the diverseness of people with whom we are are connected. Think about it.
Does Social Media Breed Conformity?

With the
development of modern democracy came the idea of public and private. For years
this separation of the public and the private has guided the behavior
of governments and how far they could intrude into our private lives. For
example, you can get arrested for public obscenity - but for the police to
enter your home they have to produce a search warrant laying out clear reasons
why they need to violate your right to privacy.
In private -
that is to say at home with family or friends - people were sealed away from
the eyes of society and allowed to make their own rules in their own
households. Outside the home, however, the act of simply being visible and
participating in society made a person subject to the rules of that
society- which were created, dictated and enforced by the members of society.
While a man might be arrested by police for breaking a law, he would also be
shunned by his peers if he did not adhere to what was considered acceptable
behavior in terms of manners, dress and actions.
In the Age of Social Media, Will Anything Be Private?
The modern age of social
media, however, has blurred the lines so far that it is questionable whether
such a thing as a private sphere even exists anymore. We Twitter about the
minutiae of our day and post status updates on Facebook and MySpace that our
employers and prospective employers can find and use to judge whether we are
suitable employees - based on information we willing provide.We have social media profiles that mix friends, family, co-workers and business contacts with no real way to separate them and keep some parts of our information private. Some social media platforms - Facebook and Flickr, for example - enable us to differentiate between public and private - but many do not. People post videos on YouTube and photographs on Flickr, MySpace and Facebook of things they do in their private lives which bleed over into the public domain - and have led to arrests and firings.
We even have tools like the new Google Latitude which allows our friends and even strangers to track our every move - and identify us because we have our picture splashed across our various public profiles.
Increasingly, we are willingly placing our private activities into the public domain and this gives society more of a say in how we should behave and more control over our actions - if you post a drunken photo of yourself on Facebook taken when you were supposedly home with the flu and your employer finds it, would you really be surprised if there were repercussions? If you Twittered negatively about a client and you lost their business, could you complain?
The Implications of a Global Public Sphere
While social media has done a wonderful job of
expanding what we consider to be our society from a village to a world, it has
also led to new ways of monitoring and moderating our behavior - but because
global society is a new phenomenon, in many instances it's also a case of mob
rule - how many people have been bullied or hounded off public forums for
violating some unspoken code of conduct they did not fully understand?
We have yet to really understand the full
implications of making our private lives fully public. While it may lead to
more interaction between cultures, it may also lead to greater social
conformity worldwide. In a world where people complain about the destruction of
the character of local towns and villages by global brands, social media may
prove an even worse disaster as people no longer take their social cues from
their neighbors but from a range of "friends" from around the world.
Will the public gaze of an online audience lead
to the creation of an international set of rules about not just behavior, but
also the creation of a new set of cultural norms to be followed worldwide - and
hence the disappearance of national cultures?
Increasing use of social media will also lead
governments to redefine their own mandate in terms of how to use the public
sphere to monitor the private sphere and what level of governance and
regulation is appropriate - and how do you govern a virtual space where only
some of the inhabitants fall under your legal jurisdiction?
As we go forward into this new, public world we
should be as aware of the dangers and the implications of making our lives
entirely public as we are of the benefits. It is now time to be careful with your online activities. Just click on the play to learn how dangerous it can be.
Another thoughtful post! I think the spread of the Internet has led to both conformity (as you point out) and diversity. People who like unusual things or don't quite fit in within their town can join a larger online community for support and companionship. You can read about and look at experiences of others from around the world, and share ideas. It's pretty incredible when you think about the possibilities.
ReplyDeleteThat said I agree that there is a struggle manage public and private faces between real life and online. Online there is a tendency to paint an idealized image of yourself, that can be unrealistic. That said we often don't want to expose too much private info online because who knows what will happen to it. We are just beginning to get a grasp of social media and its effects in culture, society, and psychology.
Asubonteng, this is a wonderful post as it highlights the social and cultural implications that social media may be having on a broad and global scale. I thought your posts on the points about conformity and a global public sphere to be really insightful. Your point about how the growing digital community will continue to effect policy and decision-making as well as raise questions about legal standing and authority was an excellent dynamic to add to this blog post.
ReplyDelete